Island Brothers Catering
  • Home
  • Carry Out Meals
  • Full Service Catering
  • Menus
    • Full Service Menu
    • Carryout Menu
  • Carry Out Order Form
  • More
    • Home
    • Carry Out Meals
    • Full Service Catering
    • Menus
      • Full Service Menu
      • Carryout Menu
    • Carry Out Order Form
Island Brothers Catering
  • Home
  • Carry Out Meals
  • Full Service Catering
  • Menus
    • Full Service Menu
    • Carryout Menu
  • Carry Out Order Form

Carry Out Meals

Designed to quickly and easily feed your family or a large group. Choose your menu and let Island Brothers take care of the food. Pick it up or have it delivered. Either way, it arrives hot and ready to serve. Just set it on the table, put a fork in it and enjoy.


Perfect for informal weddings hosted at a rented beach front home, a retirement party at your house, a birthday party in your backyard, a church supper in the community hall, or just a dinner for your multi-family vacation.

  Feed your group easily and cost effectively as possible.


Full pans feed 20–24 and half pans feed 10–12 when served as a meal with 2 entrées and 2 sides. Mix and match for variety or to fit your guests.  


Not sure, give your favorites, fill out the information and submit the form.  We will provide experienced feedback, provide popular and delicious options, and make sure you not only have the right food, but the right amount of food.


USE THE MENU BELOW TO MAKE YOUR SELECTIONS THEN CLICK OVER TO THE ORDERING FORM TO SUBMIT YOUR ORDER. 



All menus are subject to a 10% service fee and 6.75% sales tax.
Delivery is $25–$45 depending on address. Pickup is free at Daddy Mac’s Beach Grille in Surf City.

--------- Click here to order your carry out meal ---------

Lasagna Meal

Choose you favorite lasagna for your menu or add a Caesar salad and garlic bread a meal.

Meat Lasagna — Half $65 | Full $125
Fresh ground beef

Cheese Lasagna — Half $55 | Full $110
Classic, with ricotta

Seafood Lasagna — Half $95 | Full $175
Shrimp, scallops and mahi mahi


Make it a meal: add Caesar salad and garlic bread for $40 half pan / $75 full pan.

Fajitas Meal

Minimum 24 Guests Per Order. Select any 2 fajitas fillings, with Mexican Rice and Black Beans as si

Choose Two Fillings
Served with peppers and onions
Grilled Vegetables  /  Chicken   /  Steak — add $1.50 per person  / Mahi Mahi — add $2.50 per person


Toppings Included
Cheddar cheese / Salsa / Scallions / Chipotle sour cream / Peruvian slaw / Flour or corn tortillas


Add-Ons
Guacamole — $3.50 per person     Queso — $2.00 per person

Shrimp Boil

A meal all to itself. Peel n Eat Shrimp, Andouille Sausage, Corn on the Cob and Red Potatoes

Shrimp Boil — Half $155 | Full $300
21–25 count shrimp, andouille sausage, corn on the cob and red potatoes

Fresh Seafood

Fresh Fish Fillets — Market price
Lightly seasoned and broiled: mahi mahi, swordfish, corvina, grouper or salmon

Shrimp & Grits — Half $80 | Full $155
Petite shrimp in a creamy cheesy bacon bell pepper sauce over grits

Maryland-Style Crab Cakes — $75 per 1/2 dozen
all backfin, no filler, simply the best around.

Crab Stuffed Flounder — $70 per 1/2 dozen
Flounder fillets stuffed with Maryland-style crab cake, imperial sauce

Chicken and Pork

Chicken Marsala — Half $65 | Full $125
Breaded chicken in a mushroom Marsala sauce

Chicken Stir-Fry — Half $65 | Full $125
Tender chicken with onions and peppers

Chicken Teriyaki — Half $55 | Full $110
Grilled with sweet teriyaki

Pork Medallions with Herb Cream — Half $60 | Full $120
Pork tenderloin in an herb cream sauce

Chopped BBQ — Half $55 | Full $110
Chopped pork with tangy vinegar Carolina BBQ sauce

Steak

Sliced London Broil — Half $70 | Full $135
Marinated and grilled, served in a light au jus

Beef Stir-Fry — Half $80 | Full $155
Tender cuts of steak with onions and peppers

Italian

Chicken Alfredo — Half $55 | Full $105
Bowtie pasta and chicken breast in a cheese cream sauce

Shrimp Alfredo — Half $65 | Full $125
Bowtie pasta and petite shrimp in a cheese cream sauce

APPETIZERS & ADD-ONS

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail — $28 per lb
16–20 count

Large Shrimp Cocktail — $24 per lb
21–25 count

Bacon Wrapped Scallops — $39 per dozen

Crab Dip with Pita Points — $40
Serves 10–12

Garlic Bread — $25
Serves 10–12

Hush Puppies — Half $22 | Full $32

Veggie Platter — $42
Serves 12

Bread Rolls & Butter — Half $12 | Full $26

Sides

Mashed Potatoes — Half $35 | Full $70
Red potatoes, seasoned and whipped smooth

Twice Baked Potatoes — Half $40 | Full $75
Crispy shells stuffed with sour cream, cheddar and chive potato

Mainsail Loaded Potatoes — Half $40 | Full $75
Diced fried potatoes, cheddar, bacon, chives and ranch

Haricot Verts — Half $30 | Full $60
Thin green beans with onions and carrots, sautéed in garlic butter

Grilled Vegetables — Half $40 | Full $80
Seasoned squash and zucchini with onion

Carolina Cole Slaw — Half $25 | Full $45
Cabbage, carrot and love

Mixed Green Salad — Half $35 | Full $70
Red wine vinaigrette or ranch

Caesar Salad — Half $35 | Full $75
Parmesan and croutons

Greek Salad — Half $40 | Full $80
Cucumbers, olives, green peppers and feta

VEGETARIAN OPTIONS

Mac & Cheese — Half $40 | Full $75
Creamy baked macaroni and cheese

Grilled Moroccan Vegetables over Couscous — Half $55 | Full $100
Marinated squash, zucchini and onions

Pasta Salad — Half $35 | Full $75
Bowtie pasta, peppers, onions and tomatoes

Garbanzo Bean Salad — Half $35 | Full $70
Peppers, onions, tomatoes, parsley and feta

KIDS

Chicken Tenders with Honey Mustard — $20
6 pieces

Bowtie Pasta with Marinara — $14
Serves 4

Bowtie Pasta with Meatball Marinara — $22
Serves 4

Island Brothers Catering

108 North Shore Dr Surf City, NC 28445

islandbrotherscatering@gmail.com

Copyright © 2026 Island Brothers Catering - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept